McCain’s temperment
I’m a religious reader of Josh Marshall’s Talking Points Memo site. For months, he’s been writing about John McCain’s fitness for office, calling him dangerous and unpredictable. I haven’t always agreed with this, but the more I see of McCain and his campaign, the more I think that Marshall might be right.
The McCain campaign has lurched from crisis to crisis, from the badly staged “that’s not change we can believe in” speech, to sticking his foot in it during the Georgia crisis, to delaying the start of the GOP convention (supposedly due to Hurricane Gustav), to the hows and whys of the Palin selection (which seriously calls into question exactly who’s running the show in the McCain campaign), from saying that “the fundamentals of our economy are strong” one week, to deciding the next week to “suspend” his campaign to “rush” back to Washington, call for the resignation of the SEC chairman, attempt to delay the first presidential debate (and invite speculation that he did so in order to keep his running mate away from Joseph Biden next Thursday), and help scuttle the Wall Street bailout talks at the White House.
His bad poker face and short temper have gotten him in trouble before, and his arrogance is legendary. Check out this exchange between McCain and member of the public at a campaign town hall event for college-aged folks. Maybe the kid is a little shirty about how he phrases the question, but it’s still a totally legitimate question, given McCain’s age and health history. McCain gives his answer, but can’t resist sneaking in a little dig at the end. (”…you little jerk!”) It was kind of a cute remark, and it fit well into his maverick image, but it also betrayed a meanness and arrogance churning just below the surface. He was basically saying, “Who the fuck do you think you are?” And if he could let a 20-something college student get under his skin, how would he behave during tense international negotiations with a foreign adversary?
If this is the leadership and management style he plans to bring to the White House, we should all be very, very afraid. Here is a man who creates crisis, who is prone to histrionics, who repeatedly makes dangerously inaccurate statements in public, games major scheduled events, and disrupts delicate bipartisan negotiations for political gain. (”Country first” indeed!) He has a great sense of melodrama, but he also has little capacity for nuanced thought, almost no economic policy chops, and a terrible poker face.
Some would say that this is classic McCain. But that’s the problem. These are very bad traits to take to the White House, where diplomacy, negotiation, and measured debate are key. Right now the last thing we need is an administration making snap, seat-of-the-pants decisions, and veering unpredictably between melodrama and arrogance.
And McCain’s recent “hail Mary” moves have all landed with a thud. Postponing the GOP convention due to Gustav? Gustav turned out to be a wash. Picking Sarah Palin as his running mate without vetting her first? A disaster. Trying to look presidential by “suspending” his campaign and attempting to push back the debate? Another disaster. Rushing to Washington to participate in the Wall Street bailout bill talks? Another disaster. So McCain’s leadership style isn’t just dangerous and unpredictable; it’s counterproductive, too.
Frankly I have doubts about his health–both physical and mental. He often appears a little unsteady and awkward in public, with somebody almost always nearby to whisper in his ear to keep him in line. Again, who’s running the show?
There has been a lot of buzz around how and why McCain didn’t–or perhaps couldn’t–look Obama in the eye at any point during the first debate. (Arrogance? Contempt? Fear? Beta monkey/dog behavior?) But given what we now know about last week’s encounter in at the White House–in which Obama basically called McCain’s bluff–it sheds new light McCain’s body language during Friday’s debate. Maybe they both knew what millions of viewers didn’t: Obama had already handed him his hat, the day before.




